Einstar hand scanner

Hand scanners can be fiddly to use, not because they are technically complex but because, unlike a studio, you normally have to do everything yourself. Calibration, space prep, post processing. It is not that difficult to go through the instructions but it takes time.

The first scanner I tried was Shining 3D’s Einstar hand scanner, borrowed from our Storyfutures centre here at Royal Holloway.
https://www.einstar.com/


Target 3D volume capture

The capture volume is 9m in diameter of which the central 3m is the usable scanning area. There are 48 cameras arranged on the ‘poles’. They all have to be calibrated before the capture and then there can be lots of post-processing afterwards.

I was kindly invited by Allan Rankin to try the volumetric scanner at Target 3D’s studio in Tower Hill. This is normally an expensive facility. I asked the head of R&D Benjamin Walbrook what the benefit could be to Target. His reply ‘skin tones’. I was the first nude subject they had tried scanning.
https://www.target3d.co.uk


Esper scanner at Central St Martins

The Esper rig is composed of 60 cameras. This produces a high resolution, instant still capture. The technician Fred had built this rig himself. He has has also built a commercial rig which has 200 cameras and outputs a mesh of 200 million triangles.

A friend arranged for me to get a scan using the Esper rig facility at Central St Martins in Kings Cross.


Comparison

Here you can see the three results compared – Einstar hand scanner, the Esper rig, and the Target 3D volume capture.

EinstarEsper, CSM Target 3D
Texture res5k but mainly background, equivalent to about 10% of Esper I think8K2.8K, similar to Einstar but a bit softer
Mesh res5M (but low detail?)1M83k
Mesh qualityseams, worse after retopnoise on body hairslightly lumpy